Dispelling Myths About Psychiatry I

Psychiatrist_with_patient_-_Google_SearchMany people believe that psychiatric conditions aren’t as well defined as other medical diseases, that psychiatric treatments aren’t supported by as much scientific evidence, and that they don’t work as well as other medical treatments. Dr. N.L. Stotland, in her Presidential Address to the American Psychiatric Association, confronts many of the popular myths about psychiatry. This is important because many people, including many Christians, have doubts about the effectiveness of psychiatric treatment, doubts which hold them back from getting help they need. Here are some of the questions Dr. Stotland raises and her answers:

What is abnormal?

1. Are psychiatric conditions nothing more than labels for normal behaviors? Is a person with social anxiety disorder, for example, just shy?

Differentiating psychiatric conditions from normal is no different than deciding what level of blood pressure is ‘hypertension.’ A condition rises to the level of disease when it handicaps a person, is associated with bad outcomes, and/or can be treated — in psychiatry just as in the rest of medicine.

How does diagnosis work?

2. Do psychiatrists just sit around and vote psychiatric diagnoses in or out of the diagnostic manual?

Specialists look at the evidence, then judge the criteria for medical diagnoses. The difference between a benign tumor and a cancer is a matter of how many sick cells appear under the microscope. Of course, oncologists have to make that decision, and they presumably they have some sort of vote to make it official. Psychiatrists do likewise.

What causes mental illness?

3. Do we know more about what causes other diseases than we do about the causes of psychiatric illnesses?

We all know that diabetes is caused by the failure of the pancreas to secrete normal amounts of insulin. But what causes that? We say it’s an autoimmune condition — the body attacks its own insulin-secreting cells. Why does that happen? We don’t know. We do know, however, a lot about the causes of psychiatric conditions. Several of them have a strong hereditary component — they run in families. Certain kinds of childhood experiences and later traumas have an effect. Sometimes people with certain genes can become ill only under certain circumstances.

[Sources: Stotland NL. MD Presidential address. Am J Psychiatry 2009: 166:1101-1104. The Huffington Post June 20, 2014. Photo: en.wickipedia.org]


About Grose

Gordon Grose loves most to write, speak, and preach on the message of hope from the book of Job. Using drama, video, and PowerPoint, he has preached and presented this message of hope to churches around the country. Grose pastored three congregations 25 years, then served 12 years as a pastoral counselor in a Portland, Oregon counseling clinic. He now serves with Good Samaritan Counseling Services, Beaverton, OR. A graduate of Wheaton College (IL), Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary, Brandeis University, and Boston University, he comes from a rich and varied background in theological and counseling training. In 2015, Gordon published Tragedy Transformed: How Job's Recovery Can Provide Hope For Yours, a book about turning to Job for hope after tragedy. If you have experienced life challenges or personal tragedy, visit his Transforming Tragedy (gordongrose.com) blog to learn more. TragedyTransformed.com provides a sample of Gordon's speaking as well as an opportunity to purchase copies of his book.
This entry was posted in Hope for the Hurting, Mental Illness. Bookmark the permalink.